|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
Track and field’s longest-standing world record was set in Munich 43 years ago when the Czech runner Jarmila Kratochvilova ran 800 meters in 1 minute, 53.28 seconds. Coming in fifth, nine seconds later, was Doriane Lambelet Coleman.
The Swiss-American athlete, who competed as Doriane Lambelet and Doriane McClive at different points in her career, had recently graduated from Cornell University, where she was a national champion runner. She entered the race hoping to secure her spot on the Swiss national team for the upcoming World Championships. By the halfway point, she knew it wouldn’t happen, she told The Telegraph in September. She had run so fast to keep up, there was no way she could maintain the pace.
Even then, Coleman suspected that Kratochvilova—a 32-year-old who had reportedly competed in the 800 only three times before—had an unfair advantage. Her time was just too fast.
“Everybody understood that for athletes who came from behind the Iron Curtain, this is what they’re going to look like. They looked like they were on drugs, and they sounded like they were on drugs,” Coleman told the British paper.
Coleman wasn’t alone in her suspicions, which have grown across the track world since the revelation of Czechoslovakia’s secret doping program. One of the most common steroids used, by men and women, was testosterone, which males naturally produce in much larger amounts than females. Others speculated about her sex directly, Slate reported. “You had no idea it was a woman,” one runner said. (“As for drugs, I never took any. Never,” Kratochvilova told The New York Times in 1999; the paper reported she never failed a drug test at a competition.)
After Munich, Coleman continued her athletic career for a few years, then followed a similar track in law. She wrote anti-doping guidelines for USA Track & Field, then entered academia and joined the faculty at Duke University, studying sex discrimination. So when trans women in sports became a dominant political issue, it was only natural that she would take it on.

Coleman believes the progressive emphasis on gender identity is unduly provocative. She argues that trans women should be banned from competitive women’s sports on fairness grounds but encouraged to compete at grassroots levels, which she says ensures inclusion without causing harm. She says this is a fact-based middle ground—a common-sense approach, as the subtitle of her 2024 book On Sex and Gender puts it.
Nonetheless, that work has made her a favorite legal scholar among conservatives seeking to curb trans rights. Republicans in 12 states, including North Carolina, have cited her by name in bills to ban trans women from competing in all women’s sports, including at noncompetitive and community levels.
Some trans activists say that what Coleman calls common sense is nothing more than dressed-up hate speech that puts trans people at risk.
“Everything that’s grown out of her project of promoting to the world that it is common sense or reasonable to discriminate against trans adults has led to extreme harm,” said Vivian Taylor, one of the founders of a group called Stand Up for Trans Women Duke.
Others have begun to follow Coleman’s path. Democrats won nationwide in this month’s midterms, but many did so by backing away from culture war issues like the trans sports debate, and liberal bastions Colorado and Washington passed new restrictions on trans women in sports.
“It’s kind of like being sandwich meat,” Coleman told The Assembly recently. “Nothing you say makes anybody happy.”
Vive la Différence
Coleman is very clear: She is a liberal.
She was quite literally born into it. Her father is a descendant of William and Ellen Craft, an enslaved couple who galvanized abolitionists and became a national cause célèbre when they fled north in 1848. Coleman married into it as well: Her husband, Jim, leads Duke’s Wrongful Convictions Clinic. Hers is a civil rights family.
But more than her abolitionist forebears, her politics are defined by her mother, a Swiss seamstress named Bluette who raised Coleman alone after her father died, and to whom On Sex and Gender is dedicated.
Coleman writes in the book that Bluette passed on what she calls a “vive la différence” approach to sex and gender. Coleman seeks equal protection before the law for men and women but is not shy about defending biological differences between male and female bodies. Coleman often cites her athletic experience to justify it, saying all elite female athletes know what it’s like to lose to ordinary men. She even keeps a photo in her office taken at the end of a 1984 10K race. Beside her is an unknown man also running in the public event.
“I’m one of the best female athletes in the country at the time, in my event,” she told The Assembly. “And this is some rando.”
Coleman’s scholarship has long explored legal questions about differences between the sexes. After graduating from Georgetown University Law Center in 1988, she entered private practice, which included her pro bono work on doping for USA Track & Field. Since entering academia in 1994, Coleman has done interdisciplinary work on sex, medicine, and sports, including whether minors can legally consent to medical treatment, multiculturalism, and doping.

Shortly after Coleman joined the Duke faculty in 2007, another woman with a muscular physique, like Kratochvilova, began dominating the 800 meters internationally.
Though Caster Semenya, a South African runner, was identified as a female at birth and has lived as one throughout her life, she was accused of secretly being male after winning a world championship in 2009. Sports authorities required her to undergo sex testing as a result.
It included the first gynecological exam of Semenya’s life, she wrote in her 2023 memoir, and revealed she has XY chromosomes, not the XX pairing most women have, and undescended testicles producing testosterone in the typical male range. The trait stems from a difference in sex development, or DSD—a suite of conditions sometimes referred to as being intersex.
Because the scientific debate over whether women with DSDs have advantages in sports has centered largely on the role of testosterone, which is also used in doping, Coleman says she started fielding questions from reporters about the policy implications. Semenya’s case pushed her to dive into the topic more seriously.
“Nothing you say makes anybody happy.”
Doriane Coleman, Duke Law professor
She spent seven years “deep reading” before writing a 2017 journal article titled “Sex in Sport” that lays out the basic positions Coleman later refined in On Sex and Gender.
Coleman argues that the science is clear: The male body is bigger and stronger, has a different heart structure, and is better suited to some things than the female body (and vice versa). Though Coleman is careful to dismiss the “junk science” of past eras that assumed women were less intelligent and destined for caring roles, she nonetheless says that it’s a biological fact that males and females are different. In On Sex and Gender, Coleman even argues that there is some evidence men are better at visuospatial tasks than women, potentially explaining their dominance in chess.
“There’s simply no way to pretend sex isn’t binary,” she wrote.
Though not trained as a scientist, Coleman has long collaborated with biologists and sports scientists who agree. There’s a consensus in the field that males have an athletic advantage over females, which is one reason why trans men have not attracted the same attention as trans women. They don’t raise the same competitive fairness questions.
Coleman points to large studies and meta-analyses finding the advantage is retained by women with DSDs and trans women, even after they undergo gender-affirming hormone treatment.
The latter conclusion is highly contested.
“Those questioning simplistic understandings of sex—scientists among them—are hardly unscientific, but rather keen observers of the science of sex biology,” medical anthropologist Katrina Karkazis wrote in The Lancet. Other scientists argue the evidence for retained male advantage in trans women and women with DSDs is too weak, thanks to the lack of randomized controlled trials and an even greater lack of studies on trans women athletes in particular. Joanna Harper, a leading researcher in the field, told The Assembly she knows of just six.
“Non-athletic trans women often avoid activities that will result in increased strength and muscle mass and so on because they don’t want to look like men,” Harper said, so treatment could have different impacts on trans athletes compared to the broader trans population.
Coleman, though, thinks the quality of evidence is on her side. She argues that anyone with male physiology and endocrinology has an unfair advantage in competition with females. That includes trans women and women with certain DSDs.
Friends and Enemies
Around the time Coleman publicly entered the fray with her journal article, the culture war around women’s sports took off.
Coleman and her allies felt women’s sports were under threat. When Semenya won gold in the women’s 800 at the 2016 Rio de Janeiro Olympics, both other podium finishers had DSDs as well, even though DSDs only affect between .02% and 1.7% of the population, depending on which conditions are included.
World Athletics, the sport’s governing body, later banned women with DSDs from competing in some events, including Semenya’s preferred 800 meters, unless they suppressed their natural testosterone levels. Semenya sued over the rule in 2018; Coleman was an expert witness for the federation. (Semenya lost, but the case dragged on until 2025.)
She praised Semenya’s dignity and acknowledged the difficulty of her situation. But in 2019, Coleman wrote that “we aren’t fooled” that women with Y chromosomes like Semenya are “simply ‘women with hyperandrogenism,’ or ‘women with high T.’”

Coleman also insists on calling Semenya “biologically male” rather than a woman with a DSD. “The balls are there, albeit undescended,” Coleman wrote in On Sex and Gender. (“I’m a different kind of woman, I know, but I’m still a woman,” Semenya wrote.)
Coleman’s work gained more visibility when congressional Democrats proposed the 2019 Equality Act. The bill would have prohibited discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity, in addition to sex. But their approach would have defined sex only in terms of identity, not reproductive biology. Coleman argued doing so would have prohibited all sex classifications, including sports programs set aside for women. She saw that as an “extraordinary provocation,” tantamount to denying the biological reality of sex. She accepted an invitation from congressional Republicans to testify against the bill.
At the time, Coleman argued that trans women who hadn’t gone through puberty as males should be allowed to compete in women’s sports and that all trans women should be included when the purpose was social rather than competitive, like recreational leagues and club teams. (She later changed her mind about trans women who don’t go through male puberty, pointing to new scientific evidence.)
A year later, Idaho became the first state to introduce a bill citing her. The law made it illegal for all trans women and girls to participate in any level of women’s sports at any public school.
“It was surreal, and I was angry,” Coleman said. “I mean, who gets their name put in a bill?”
The fact that she was cited for biology statistics, not her legal arguments, makes Coleman think she was just a prop. “The only reason they use me is because I’m a feminist law professor from Duke,” she said.
Arizona lawmakers introduced a similar bill the same year, then nine more states did in 2021, including North Carolina, followed by North Dakota in 2023. The North Carolina law passed over then-Gov. Roy Cooper’s veto; it bans trans girls and women from competing on any women’s teams in middle school, high school, or college, including intramurals. Coleman criticized that bill for not distinguishing between different levels of sports, among other things.
To add insult to injury, the U.S. Soccer Federation cited Coleman’s work in a 2020 lawsuit to justify paying its women’s team less than its men’s. Coleman objected to that, too. Female athletes may not be able to beat their male counterparts, she argued, but they still produce enormous social value.
Coleman criticizes Republicans’ treatment of the trans community—“I think a lot of the legislation is horrible, and I think that undoubtedly their lives are being made more difficult as a result,” she said—but, ultimately, she places the blame on the trans rights movement.
“I’m not nearly so sympathetic to those people in the trans rights movement who decided that the way to get trans rights was to pretend either that sex isn’t real or that it’s gender identity, because I think that they ignited this fire that threatens to burn their house down,” Coleman said.

So Goes Uganda
The fight exploded into public at Duke when Coleman edited a special issue of the school’s Law and Contemporary Problems in 2022.
It included an essay from Kathleen Stock, a British philosopher and perhaps the most prominent academic of the “gender critical feminism” movement that, like Coleman, argues sex is binary and immutable. Stock had recently resigned a faculty role at the University of Sussex after frequent protests from students calling for her to be fired.
Duke students began leveling the same accusations at Coleman. “I hate that part of my tuition money has gone to pay her salary,” Dylan Jarrett, then a third-year law student who resigned as editor in chief of the journal over Stock’s essay, told the Chronicle of Higher Education. An officer in Duke Law’s LGBTQ group said Coleman’s work was “at its core transphobic.”
Taylor, the founder of Stand Up for Trans Women Duke, had graduated from master’s programs in the Duke divinity and public policy schools by then, but she has still been adamantly protesting Coleman. Taylor is now a first-year law student at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, where her torts class uses a textbook Coleman published.
A trans woman and Army veteran, Taylor worked as the executive director of Integrity USA, the Episcopal Church’s national LGBTQ nonprofit, before coming to Duke. At the time, Uganda—where the denomination has a large membership—was passing a slate of anti-gay laws, including one that punished homosexuality with life in prison. The original draft proposed the death penalty. Taylor worked with activists to oppose it. (The law was later struck down on procedural grounds, but a new version passed in 2023.)
She said the experience made her extra cautious about laws aimed at gay and trans people, and she and her allies believe the conservative push to ban trans women from women’s sports isn’t only about athletics.
“Everything that’s grown out of her project of promoting to the world that it is common sense or reasonable to discriminate against trans adults has led to extreme harm.”
Vivian Taylor, founder of Stand Up for Trans Women Duke
There just aren’t very many trans women in elite sports, they point out. NCAA president Charlie Baker told Congress in 2024 that he knew of fewer than 10 trans athletes out of the 510,000 across its schools. Meanwhile, the conservative Heritage Foundation is now advocating wholesale changes to Title IX, the key legal protection against sex discrimination. The think tank argues that schools should be able to replace varsity women’s sports with cheerleading, dance, yoga, and similar intramural activities.
The Trump administration has also passed numerous restrictions on gender-affirming care, 28 states have banned such treatment for minors, and some conservatives have suggested that their gender identity means trans people shouldn’t appear in classrooms.
Taylor also takes particular issue with other self-identified liberals like the Women’s Sports Policy Working Group, which Coleman co-founded in 2021 with tennis icon Martina Navratilova, former Olympic swimmer Donna de Varona, and others. To counter trans activists’ claims that there aren’t enough elite trans athletes to worry about, the working group compiled a list in 2023 of trans women who won competitions—at all levels.
Two anonymous websites, SheWon and HeCheated, which the working group lists as allies, have taken that even further. They have named minors, including people who won nonsporting events like prom queen, which trans advocates say drives targeted harassment. A trans Middlebury College swimmer named Lia Smith took her own life a few months after HeCheated posted about her.

Coleman left the working group in January 2022, roughly a year before the group announced its own list, and she has publicly opposed targeting minors since then. “All kids should have the opportunity somehow to play sports, full stop. All kids includes trans kids,” Coleman told the San Francisco Chronicle in August when asked to comment about a 12-year-old bullied and harassed by her rowing team.
Taylor is unmoved. She notes that Coleman wrote about trans youths by name in a journal article—two Connecticut high schoolers whose case had been extensively covered by the media already—and that she has not spoken out against the working group as it promoted HeCheated and SheWon.
Coleman’s writing “dumped a huge amount of poison in the ecosystem,” Taylor says. At various points, she compared Coleman to the founder of a fictional “North Carolina Society for the Promotion of Methamphetamine Use” who balks when it sells drugs to teens, and to a hypothetical KKK member who opposes discriminating against Black children but not Black adults. She also said the professor’s anti-bullying stance is “two-faced damage control,” adding that her quote to the San Francisco Chronicle came after Stand Up for Trans Women Duke began protesting Coleman’s ties to the working group.
“I think that a lot of Doriane Coleman’s success has come from the fact that she always argues, ‘Well, I’m the common-sense middle ground,’” Taylor said. “No one is allowed to disagree with common sense. The fact is, this lady was hurting people.”
Taylor even suspects Coleman is secretly running HeCheated, citing things like the anonymous founder saying in an interview (with a founder of the working group) that they work at a university. But there is no evidence that Coleman is involved. “I have nothing to do with HeCheated.org,” Coleman said. “I don’t know who runs it. The claim that I am and do is an actionable fabrication given how it’s being used.” (The Assembly contacted the person who runs the site but was unable to identify them.)
The tenor of the critiques clearly irks Coleman and contributes to her sense that she and her allies are unfairly attacked.
Shifting Terrain
Despite the venom of the public debate, sports governing bodies have largely agreed with Coleman’s argument on who should be able to compete in women’s sports.
The International Olympic Committee limited eligibility to those without a Y chromosome for the 2028 Los Angeles Games, and World Athletics now has a similar approach (though some athletes with DSDs can compete if their testosterone levels are kept low enough). The NCAA restricted eligibility in 2025 to those identified as female at birth.
Even some trans activists have moderated their demands. In 2022, many argued against testosterone-suppression requirements, including for athletes with DSDs. One of the students protesting the journal issue Coleman edited told The Chronicle of Higher Education that testosterone testing is transphobic.
Today, “The vast majority of people who are trans advocates are fine with some sort of hormonal guidance,” Taylor told The Assembly.
Still, the other half of Coleman’s so-called “middle ground” approach—letting trans women and kids play in lower-level, community sports—feels unlikely right now.

The Women’s Sports Policy Working Group, for instance, has grown more restrictive. It now argues against trans women participating in women’s sports under any circumstances. They even oppose letting trans women practice and travel with women’s teams without competing.
And the line between recreational and competitive is being pushed further back into childhood, especially as youth sports become ever more competitive.
Coleman says she has given up hope of her preferred grassroots sports policies passing.
“I’ve definitely lost this battle,” she said. “I acknowledge that I’ve lost it, and I’ve removed myself from the hopes of being able to influence policy here. Because people are just so entrenched, and I honestly don’t have the energy to deal with it.”
That silence sits uneasily with trans advocates, given her outspokenness about their tactics. In On Sex and Gender, Coleman writes at length about problems she sees in the Transgender Journalists Association style guide and how media reported on the Semenya case. She even laments the adoption of the term “bonus hole” for vagina—a term that has never seen widespread use. She doesn’t mention anti-trans activists’ purposefully provocative misgendering of trans people, their use of slurs, or the trend of calling trans people “mentally ill.”
That imbalance is one reason that Coleman is seen as an ally of those with “animus” toward trans people, said Harper, the scientist who studies trans athletes.
Harper, a trans woman herself, agrees with Coleman on the need for a middle-ground policy. They used to collaborate, along with the Women’s Sports Policy Working Group. But Harper split with them as their stances became more restrictive. (She argues that trans women should be allowed to compete with sport-specific restrictions.)
“Doriane has been friendly towards me on a personal level ever since I met her,” she said. “I can state that unequivocally. Where she lies versus the trans population as a whole, I am less clear on. I’m certainly not convinced that she herself has personal animus towards the trans community. I’m not convinced she doesn’t, either.”
Coleman told The Assembly that she had no obligation to balance her critiques of the left and right. Intellectually, she’s not as interested in what conservatives are doing.
“My job is not to fix all of the things that have gone wrong for the trans rights movement,” she said.




You must be logged in to post a comment.