|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
The Philip Rivers experiment at NC State would be odd enough by virtue of his coaching resume, coming straight from a private Alabama high school. That hasn’t happened at a major program in more than 40 years.
Throw in how few quarterbacks of Rivers’ stature have gone down the coaching route after retiring, and the Wolfpack’s new football coach is truly a step into the unknown.
It’s the latest illustration of the new era of vibes-based hiring in college sports.
It’s not the first time this has happened in the Triangle in this new age wherein past practice no longer guarantees future results.
Bill Belichick? Vibes. North Carolina hired the NFL legend with almost no college experience in a big swing at football relevance instead of a more accomplished (and cheaper) college coach. Big name, big expectations, big expense, and little to show for it thus far. The Tar Heels could have had a .500 team for a lot less.
Michael Malone? Vibes. It’s hard to imagine UNC trusting the fabled Carolina basketball family to an outsider in any year before 2026. But with a daughter on campus and an NBA championship ring on his hand, Malone was worth a shot given how bare the Dean Smith/Roy Williams coaching tree had become.
Justin Gainey? No vibes, because that was as by-the-book a hire as they come: an NC State basketball alum who loves the school and paid his dues as an assistant to a legendary coach, Tennessee’s Rick Barnes. But it was also a move to stabilize the program after the one-year Will Wade whirlwind that had more than a whiff of vibes to it, bringing in a proud rule-breaker when all the old rules were on their way out the window.
So at a time when highly paid rosters of college-aged mercenaries are wiping out the decades-old method of building a program through recruiting and development, why not try something different?
The boosters have promised a competitive budget, so if NC State puts the right staff around Rivers, both on the field and in the front office, there’s no reason his lack of experience should be a disqualifying factor. He brings presence and prestige as one of the school’s most famous football products, not to mention the Wolfpack’s top quarterback recruit who also happens to be his son.
If nothing else, NC State can learn from its rival in Chapel Hill. In his first season, Belichick brought along his best friend as general manager, who assembled an expensive, underwhelming roster before exiting in disgrace; entrusted his son with a dismal defense before he too exited under murky circumstances; and indulged his now-allegedly-ex-girlfriend’s main-character syndrome. Shorn of that baggage, UNC has looked like a functional football team this year, if nothing close to what the boosters imagined.

Rivers replaces a coach very much of the older school. Dave Doeren’s best teams were built on players who he and his staff recruited for their potential, regardless of how many stars were next to their name. Those players stuck around long enough to get better and peak in a few seasons, even if the Wolfpack never managed to make it to the ACC Championship Game, let alone win a title for the first time since 1979.
Doeren tried to adjust to the new way of doing things, like bringing in more transfers for immediate upgrades. But his best players often departed for more lucrative opportunities, leaving the program operating on the thinnest of talent margins. He was built for an era when you could craft a team over a period of seasons and summers, with an eye to the long term.
College football is all about instant gratification now because there’s too much money on the line—for players and schools alike—to be patient. Maybe someone will be able to moneyball their way into winning through recruiting and retention, but so far only schools at the very top of the pyramid like Ohio State and Southern California have the resources to do it the old way.
That’s a very different landscape than the one Rivers played in at NC State, as jarring a disconnect as the one between his profile and that of other coaches who have gotten jobs at the ACC level.
Historically, of the very few who took college jobs straight from the high school ranks, most flopped. Trent Dilfer won the Super Bowl that Rivers never did but was a massive bust coaching at the University of Alabama at Birmingham. Tony Sanchez lasted five sub-.500 seasons at University of Nevada Las Vegas. Gerry Faust had a fitful three-year tenure at Notre Dame back in the early 1980s.

Even coaches famous for their high school success generally didn’t go straight to the top college job. Art Briles was a Texas high school legend but he did a three-year stint on the Texas Tech staff before getting the head job in Houston. (Briles, at least, was successful on the field before later overseeing a disgraceful scandal at Baylor.)
As for Rivers’ peers under center in the NFL, many have gone into television: Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Peyton Manning, Russell Wilson. The ones that stayed in the game have most frequently ended up in front offices, like Matt Ryan and John Elway, rather than grind it out on the sideline. Not even Bart Starr could win in Green Bay, post-Vince Lombardi.
That makes Rivers entirely sui generis, “One of one,” as NC State athletic director Boo Corrigan put it in a press release announcing Rivers’ arrival last Friday, although Corrigan meant it as a tribute to his stature within the Wolfpack community, not a commentary on the novelty of the hire.

There are, indeed, very few people who could pull this off. Maybe Rivers is one of them. Certainly, no one doubts what he means to NC State, or what NC State means to him.
At a time when schools are pouring money into football and many have more of it than NC State, zigging when others are zagging may be the Wolfpack’s best option. It may be the Wolfpack’s only option.
The stakes are enormous, with the College Football Playoff expanding to 24 teams—the Wolfpack likely would have made a hypothetical 24-team field at least twice in Doeren’s tenure—and another potential reshuffling of conferences in the next five to 10 years as television contracts expire.
By traditional standards, there may not be much more than vibes to recommend Rivers for the job. In 2026, maybe that’s exactly what NC State needs.





You must be logged in to post a comment.