Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Last April, a federal appeals court ruled that a former UNC-Chapel Hill student was denied his constitutional right to due process because he wasn’t allowed to cross-examine two female students who filed sexual misconduct complaints against him.

Now, the UNC System is revamping its policies for campus disciplinary hearings in response to that decision.

The student, a former Morehead-Cain scholar known in the lawsuit as Jacob Doe, in 2023 anonymously sued the UNC System, UNC-CH, and several administrators over their handling of the case. In 2021, four female students, who are referred to as Jane Roe 1, 2, 3, and 4, had accused him of sexual misconduct. University hearing panels found Doe responsible for misconduct in the matters brought by Jane Roe 1 and 4, and he was expelled from the university. 

Per the appeals court ruling, Doe argued he was not able to adequately cross-examine the complainants because Jane Roe 1 left partway through the proceedings and Jane Roe 4 did not attend the hearing. The court agreed with him that that wasn’t fair and said he could continue suing to be reinstated at UNC-CH, though he couldn’t seek monetary damages. (Doe and the defendants settled out of court in August.)

“Going forward, cross-examination will materially assist in ensuring a meaningful hearing in higher education disciplinary proceedings,” Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson III wrote in the unanimous opinion.

A committee of the UNC System’s Board of Governors will consider a series of related changes to the discipline policy for all of its campuses on Wednesday. If the group votes in favor, the full board will vote on the measure at its next meeting in January.

“The University of North Carolina is committed to administering student disciplinary proceedings in a manner that is consistent with applicable law and due process requirements, while also being mindful of the importance of having a student disciplinary process that is integrated into the educational experience of students,” the new policy reads. “This policy supports that goal by establishing consistent procedures for student disciplinary proceedings.”

The new policy would prohibit students from serving as “hearing officers,” the officials charged with overseeing disciplinary proceedings, determining whether the burden of proof against the accused student is met, and issuing sanctions. Instead, the role must be filled by a trained university employee or contractor. It has become somewhat rare for universities to task students with enforcing proper conduct among their peers; UNC-CH ended its century-old student-run honor court system two years ago in favor of a “conduct board” model run by university staff. 

As in the existing policy, the proposed measure distinguishes between “minor” and “serious” violations of a university’s code of conduct. A serious violation is defined as any misconduct that carries possible sanctions of a suspension of at least one semester or expulsion; a minor violation is any misconduct with lesser sanctions. 

In either classification, university officials designated to oversee the disciplinary process would review reports of alleged misconduct and determine whether to initiate a hearing. The student may tap an “advisor,” defined in the policy as a licensed attorney or non-attorney advocate, to represent them during the proceedings. 

The student can opt instead for mediation, but in serious cases that proceed to a hearing, campuses would be required to follow additional procedures to protect the accused student’s due process rights.

For instance, the student or their advisor must be “afforded a meaningful opportunity to question the evidence and any witnesses” as well as the university official who presents the basis for the charges. They must also be allowed to present evidence in support of themselves, provided the information “is relevant to the charge or other evidence presented and does not otherwise infringe the rights of other students.” And ahead of hearings in serious cases, the university must provide the accused student with any exculpatory evidence, meaning information it has gathered that would demonstrate the student was not responsible for the misconduct. 

The student may also “challenge the credibility” of the complainant or witnesses. The federal appeals court ruling in Doe’s case stated that the hearing officer cited university policy to prohibit Doe from “presenting evidence to impeach Roe 4’s credibility.”

Under the new policy, the hearing officer in serious cases must be external to the university and chosen from a list of trained, qualified individuals maintained by the UNC System office. They could include retired judges, lawyers, mediators, or “other appropriate individuals,” per the policy. The officer may impose limits on cross-examination “to guard against concerns about, among other things, harassment, prejudice, confusion of the issues, the witness’ safety, or interrogation that is repetitive or only marginally relevant.”

Students who are found responsible for misconduct may appeal the decision on any of three grounds: that they were not given a fair hearing due to procedural errors, such as a university official or hearing officer with a conflict of interest in the case refusing to recuse themselves; that the hearing officer’s decision or the sanction imposed “was so lacking in record support that no reasonable person could have reached the conclusion on responsibility and/or could have imposed the issued sanction;” and the discovery of new evidence. 

Students are allowed one appeal, which must be made in writing and reviewed by a designated university official. In serious cases, the official must be the chancellor, a vice chancellor, or a designee. The policy removes the ability of the accused student to appeal to their university’s board of trustees.

The policy would apply to all misconduct cases initiated on or after August 1, 2027.

Korie Dean is a higher education reporter for The Assembly and co-anchor of our weekly higher education newsletter, The Quad. She previously worked at The News & Observer, where she covered higher ed as part of the state government and politics team. She grew up in Efland and graduated from UNC-Chapel Hill.