Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

A large national bank is asking a judge to remove Randolph Health from the control of its owner, American Healthcare Systems. 

KeyBank, a publicly traded lender based in Ohio, filed a lawsuit on Tuesday in Randolph County asking the court to appoint a third-party consultant to oversee the hospital, which American Healthcare Systems bought out of bankruptcy in 2021.

Deep in debt and facing accusations of financial mismanagement, the multi-state hospital operation appears to be in peril. The firm’s two hospitals in Illinois face imminent closure due to a lack of funds. Its facility in Asheboro has suffered from supply shortages, benefits disruptions, and a recent payroll delay that unnerved its 800-person staff.

KeyBank is asking the court to put an independent operational referee in charge of the company instead of its owner, Mike Sarian, to ensure the hospital stays open and continues paying its staff. 

KeyBank has lent American Healthcare Systems at least $50 million since 2023, according to the lawsuit. 

In its suit, the bank says it identified two transfers totaling nearly $3.6 million from company accounts into Sarian’s family trust this spring. The bank also tallied $16 million in transfers from the firm to Staywell Senior Care, an Asheboro nonprofit day center for elderly patients that American Healthcare Systems also owns, and millions in transfers to the Illinois hospitals. KeyBank alleges these transfers violated its agreement by threatening Randolph Health’s financial stability.

Mike Sarian’s American Healthcare Systems owns Randolph Health in Asheboro. (Photo courtesy of Cal State LA)

The bank first notified American Healthcare Systems it had broken its loan agreement in April. The bank accuses the firm of double-pledging its assets through a different agreement it made with Medical Properties Trust, a medical facilities financier that has drawn congressional scrutiny for giving hospital owners big payouts while loading up facilities with more debt than they can handle.

Sarian texted “Get lost” in response to a request for comment about the suit. Sarian has previously defended his personal withdrawals, saying they were reimbursement for personal loans he gave to keep the company afloat or to cover his deferred $2 million annual salary. 

Over the past year, Sarian and his California-based firm have faced a cascade of lawsuits and complaints about unpaid bills from vendors. 

KeyBank’s lawsuit marks a dramatic legal escalation, however, and builds on previous allegations from Sarian’s former business partners that he used his hospitals as a cash machine. 

Local stakeholders are optimistic KeyBank’s suit could prevent the hospital from closing. Asheboro City Manager Donald Duncan accused Sarian of having “bled this hospital dry.” “It’s amazing to me that it’s still standing.”

According to the suit, American Healthcare Systems owes KeyBank more than $41 million but kept up with its payments with KeyBank until it missed its monthly $1 million deposit on November 1. 

In late October, The Assembly asked KeyBank about the hospital’s finances and payroll concerns. A spokesperson said the bank couldn’t comment on client details or pending litigation. “This is an unfortunate situation for all concerned,” the spokesperson wrote in an email.

American Healthcare Systems’ financial distress has been even more apparent at its two hospitals in Illinois. State officials there ordered both hospitals to stop receiving ambulance traffic earlier this month after payroll disruptions led to a staffing shortage, and anesthesia providers at Vista Medical Center stopped providing services, stating that they hadn’t been paid. 

On Monday, federal regulators stripped Vista of its ability to accept Medicaid payments. And on Tuesday, state leaders in Illinois rebuffed a last-ditch request for a loan to keep the hospitals through the holidays. In their scathing denial, state health officials told the firm they could not give them any more money on top of the $120 million in unpaid taxes and penalties it already owes. 

“The solution is not continuing to invest in an organization that has demonstrated a lack of integrity,” Illinois Department of Public Health leaders wrote. 

Earlier this year, Sarian’s former business partners removed him from control of 14 other hospitals owned through related companies over alleged financial fraud. Sarian in turn accused those partners of coordinating an illegal coup. 

In Randolph, local officials have asked state and federal officials to intervene for more than a year. They say they have not gotten much traction, and state lawmakers have been mostly quiet. Outgoing Republican U.S. Rep. Richard Hudson’s office signaled interest, but now appears focused on transition after the longtime politician lost his reelection earlier this month. A representative for the congressman-elect, Democrat Richard Ojeda, has not returned requests for comment. 

KeyBank’s lawsuit cites The Assembly’s reporting, including that the firm has ignored Randolph County’s request to pay back a $12 million state loan. 

Johanna F. Still is a health care reporter for The Assembly. She previously worked for the Greater Wilmington Business Journal, where she reported on economic development. She is also a photographer, and was the assistant editor of Port City Daily.