Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

North Carolina’s State Health Plan leaders didn’t have much of a choice. 

Facing a half-billion-dollar deficit last year, they attempted to balance it with three moves. The first (and most unpopular): They raised premiums by as much as $42 a month for most of the nearly 750,000 public employees, dependents, and retirees enrolled in the plan, the first increase in seven years. 

Next, they negotiated with surgeons to eliminate state employees’ out-of-pocket costs for several procedures, including spine, heart, and joint replacement surgeries. 

Finally, they steered members toward hospital systems that agreed to the lowest prices. Atrium, the state’s largest health system, pushed back; it didn’t want to give the plan a steep discount in an inflationary economic environment. 

But the plan’s leaders worked out a deal just days before open enrollment ended on November 6. The agreement took a fair amount of maneuvering and left thousands of Charlotte-area public employees, where Atrium is headquartered, confused about their coverage. 

The State Health Plan doesn’t expect to realize savings from its new tiered system until next year. In the meantime, it’s still running out of money, and the trustees voted last month to temporarily dip into $415 million worth of public employees’ retirement funds to make it through the next several months. 

Chris Jones, a North Dakota-based former senior Trump administration health adviser, said he was impressed with State Treasurer Brad Briner’s resolve. 

“Atrium knew it had the market share and the clout,” Jones said. “The health plan, I’ve got to hand it to them. Usually it’s the health plans that bend. They didn’t bend.”

‘Evil and Brilliant’

Hospital executives weren’t thrilled by the idea of a pay cut. But they wanted a guaranteed flow of patients, and the State Health Plan had plenty it could send their way. 

That gave the state leverage to shape deals. It also put politicians like Briner–and his “hospital cartel”-fighting predecessor, Dale Folwell–in uniquely adversarial roles with health systems. 

In July, the health plan cut deals with UNC Health, Novant Health, and the independent Statesville-based Iredell Health System, all of which became “preferred” providers under a new three-tiered system, which takes effect in 2027. While the rates are confidential, “preferred” health systems will likely see more state employee patients and, therefore, more revenue. 

“Usually it’s the health plans that bend. They didn’t bend.”

Chris Jones, former Trump administration health adviser

The following week, Durham-based Duke Health announced an agreement to join the plan’s middle-ground “access tier,” which will cost employees more in copays, out-of-pocket costs, and higher deductibles than premium-tier partners while keeping the system in the network. 

Atrium executives sought higher rates than the plan was willing to pay. But their proposals weren’t formal bids, which the plan had asked for and received from other health systems. The plan then placed Atrium in the plan’s out-of-network tier, which carries a $72,000 out-of-pocket maximum under a family plan, the highest amount a member could pay before insurance covers the rest. 

Atrium believed that it had the upper hand in negotiations. After all, it’s the Jupiter of North Carolina’s health care solar system. Having made more than $14 billion in 2025, it is not only the state’s most dominant hospital network but also part of a national nonprofit conglomerate whose annual revenues eclipse the state of North Carolina’s. 

If Atrium were to leave the network, state employees in and around Charlotte would be hit especially hard, since many of Atrium’s doctors, clinics, and hospitals operate there.

Atrium Health’s Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center in Winston-Salem. (Carolyn de Berry for The Assembly)

The week before open enrollment began last month, Atrium shocked state plan leaders by announcing it had created its own “affordability protection” plan tailored for public employees. It offered lower copays than they would qualify for under the state’s rules and promised it would not charge the plan more money. In other words, it was inviting state employees to use its services without the plan’s consent or constraints. 

Atrium’s tactic floored insiders. One health consultant described it as “evil and brilliant.” The plan’s leaders argued Atrium was just angling to make more money by charging higher rates and that the move imperiled its leverage with other health systems. If Atrium could make up its own “state” health plan—if it didn’t have to lower prices to treat the current plan’s patients—why should the other hospitals agree to lower costs? 

Four stakeholders The Assembly spoke to each independently compared Atrium’s play to coupon strategies used by pharmaceutical companies, which regulators and watchdog groups have criticized for tricking consumers. In those deals, drug manufacturers market coupons to patients who pay lower copays up front to buy brand-name medicine instead of generic, but the “discount” ultimately leads to higher overall costs for insurance companies, which experts say contribute to higher premiums for patients. 

Chris Berger, a spokesperson for Atrium, said the comparison is “fundamentally flawed.” 

“A patient’s relationship with a physician or care team, and the clinical services provided by a hospital, are not interchangeable in the same way,” he said. “Health care providers are not pills.”

Three days after the announcement, Briner sued Atrium and urged a judge to slap an emergency restraining order on the system. The suit called Atrium’s marketing “calculated to deceive” and argued that, by kneecapping the state’s leverage with the other health systems, it could potentially lead to the plan’s financial collapse.

State Treasurer Brad Briner oversees the State Health Plan. (Bryan Anderson for The Assembly)

Some stakeholders say Briner’s attempt to stop Atrium wasn’t really two titans clashing; it was more like David vs. Goliath, with Atrium now towering over the state. 

“The two parties are not necessarily on equal ground,” said Maureen Hensley-Quinn, a senior director at the National Academy for State Health Policy, a group that advises state health plans across the country on policy matters. Decades of relentless health care consolidation, she said, means “Providers do tend to hold more of the power in these negotiations.” 

‘Selling a Commodity’

Special Superior Court Judge Matthew Houston denied the plan’s request to block Atrium’s plans on October 14, reasoning that the state didn’t prove the plan’s allegedly imminent collapse would be Atrium’s fault. 

But two weeks later, Atrium and the State Health Plan reached an agreement. The deal’s prices are confidential, but the arrangement moved Atrium into the plan’s “access” tier, Briner announced on October 27. 

He said the rates Atrium charges the plan wouldn’t increase despite “a backdrop in health care that goes up 10 or 15%” annually.

Experts say there’s good reason to expect more clashes like this one.

“The two parties are not necessarily on equal ground. Providers do tend to hold more of the power in these negotiations.” 

Maureen Hensley-Quinn, National Academy for State Health Policy

“We just sort of assume that nonprofit providers will behave a certain way,” Hensley-Quinn said. “But they are businesses, and more and more they’re behaving as businesses, and they are selling a commodity that is essential.”

Suzanne Beasley, government relations director with the State Employees Association of North Carolina, said at a State Health Plan Board of Trustees meeting last month that she was grateful Atrium was “finally coming to the realization” that it had to adjust to do business with the plan. 

Berger, Atrium’s spokesperson, declined to make anyone available for an interview but said they were grateful to move forward with the plan. 

Looking ahead, plan leaders want members to shop for cheaper rates with top-tier partners Novant and UNC Health, even if it means driving farther. 

“They are called ‘preferred’ for a reason,” Tom Friedman, the plan’s executive administrator, told The Assembly. While a tiered system isn’t a new strategy, “It is novel to be done at such scale,” he said. 

Johanna F. Still is a health care reporter for The Assembly. She previously worked for the Greater Wilmington Business Journal, where she reported on economic development. She is also a photographer, and was the assistant editor of Port City Daily.