View This Email In Your Browser


U.S. Rep. Dan Bishop, the combative conservative best known for sponsoring the so-called โbathroom billโ eight years ago, is running to make history this November as the first Republican elected state attorney general in more than 120 years.
The last Republican elected to the office was Zeb Vance Walser, who served from 1897 to 1900. Since then, Democratsโ hold has only been broken briefly, with the appointment of Republican James Carson in 1974, who went on to lose later that same year.
Bishop believes he can finally win the coveted job, even as polls show his Democratic opponent, fellow U.S. Rep. Jeff Jackson, with a slight lead. Bishop has campaigned on restoring law and order, a mantra he repeats in debates and media appearances.
Michael Hewlett looks at how Bishop might shape an office that has long eluded Republicans in the state.
Dan Bishopโs Law & Order
The congressman and former state legislator wants to become the first Republican elected attorney general in more than a century.
โAtrophy has now taken hold of the office after Democrats have won consecutive elections for more than a century,โ Bishop said. โI intend to change that.โ
Have any suggestions for improving this newsletter or stories we should look into? Email us at courts@theassemblync.com.
Thank you for supporting The Assembly! Below are this week’s exclusive stories that are available only to our Premium Subscribers like you:
The Wheel Deal
There’s no question that the wheels of justice turn slowly, as the beginning of the oft-cited metaphor goes.
As the courts become more politicized, questions have grown about whether the result of that grindโespecially in cases challenging election law and redistricting decisionsโis always exceedingly fine, as the phrase concludes.
Cases about the legality of voting districts and election processes can often take the better part of a decade to reach resolution, allowing many election cycles to take place as they work through the courts.
That was the backdrop last week as a three-judge panel of the Superior Court held a hearing on a lawsuit the state NAACP filed six years ago challenging a 2018 General Assembly vote that led to major changes on voter IDs and the state income tax cap.
The U.S. Supreme Court had issued a ruling the previous year affirming that legislative district maps that the Republican-led General Assembly adopted in 2011 were unconstitutionally drawn with near “surgical precision” to weaken the power of the Black vote.
Now the NAACPโs case asks whether actions taken in a lawmaking body elected in racially-gerrymandered districts truly constitutes the will of the peopleโand if not, at what point should they be invalidated.
A Wake County judge ruled in favor of the NAACP in 2019, but the state Court of Appeals reversed that decision in a 2-1 ruling. It was then appealed to the state Supreme Court.
When Democrats held a 4-3 majority on the state’s highest court back in 2022, the justices split along party lines to keep the case alive, sending it back to Superior Court to respond to more questions. While not every act taken by a legislative body elected from unconstitutional gerrymandered districts should be invalidated, some should be, the justices found.
Now two Republicans and one Democrat in Superior Court will hear new arguments in the case.
Martin Warf, counsel for Republican lawmakers named in the suit, has asked for the case to be dismissed.
Counsel for the NAACP responded that filing a motion for dismissal at this point in the case was unusual. The NAACP has not yet been able to get evidence from lawmakers about how the vote came about and then question them under oath about those decisions and actions.
At the October 4 hearing, Republican Judge Cynthia Sturges from Franklin County asked why that process had not happened yet, targeting her question at the NAACP attorneys as if they had been slow-walking the case.
Kym Meyer, counsel for the NAACP, told Sturges that GOP attorneys had been against filling their requests for information until the judges had decided on whether to dismiss the case, a stance Warf acknowledged.
“The Supreme Court set down a very clear mandate,” Meyer said. “They said, ‘Here’s the test, you need to go conduct discovery, and then a lower court will look at your facts and will apply the test. And then they’ll make a determination.'”
The judges did not rule immediately after the hearing, and told participants that they planned to meet in person to discuss, without specifying when.
Any decision from the three-judge panel is likely to be appealed. Since the state Supreme Court’s 2022 ruling, Republicans have gained a 5-2 majority which could lead to a different outcome.
โ Anne Blythe

Court of Public Opinion
As candidates in the 2024 elections make their closing arguments to voters, several GOP campaigns and their surrogates have turned to the courts to try to quiet their opponents.
U.S. Rep. Dan Bishop, the Republican running for state attorney general, filed a lawsuit in Union County earlier this month against the campaign of U.S. Rep. Jeff Jackson, his Democratic opponent.
Bishop alleges that the state Democratic Party, the Democratic Attorneys General Association, the Jackson campaign and Dynata, a marketing company, were behind a poll that he says disseminated inaccurate and defamatory information about his legal career.
On October14, Republican lawmakers Sens. Buck Newton, Amy Galey, and Danny Britt, all attorneys, sent a letter to colleagues in the state Senate informing them that Newton had filed a complaint against state Supreme Court Justice Allison Riggs, a Democrat running this election, accusing her of violating the code of judicial conduct by running ads on reproductive rights.
โAs attorneys who value the integrity of our judicial process, it has become clear that Justice Riggs is guided more by the politics of winning an election rather than honoring the Code of Judicial Conduct,โ Newton, Galey, and Britt wrote in their letter.ย
Riggs responded to the letter on X, formerly Twitter, saying the senators “had falsely accused” her. โThis is a troubling moment for judicial independence in our state,โ Riggs wrote. โMembers of the legislature should never be able to weaponize the nonpartisan Judicial Standards Commission to assist a political ally in winning a judicial election.โ
The ad in question states that, โAs the youngest woman to serve on the NC Supreme Court, and the only woman of childbearing years serving on any of the stateโs appellate courts, Justice Riggs has been, and will continue to be, outspoken about her values on reproductive freedom.โ
Riggs also mentions Lt. Gov. Mark Robinson, the Republican running for governor who has spoken at at least one event about wanting to ban abortion with no exceptions. The Riggs ad then shows a picture of her opponent, Republican Jefferson Griffin, and states that he could decide if a ban becomes law.
Griffin, a Court of Appeals judge, signed onto a decision last year that stated “life begins at conception”โan opinion that has since been withdrawn.
Griffin released an ad after Newtonโs complaint alleging that the Judicial Standards Commission is investigating Riggs for her “false ads.”
Press Millen, an attorney representing Riggs, sent Griffin a cease-and-desist letter, calling claims in the ad false and adding that the commission had not informed Riggs of a formal investigation.
Millen told The Assembly this week that he thought the senatorsโ letter seemed “frivolous.”
“She’s not saying how she would rule on any case,” Millen said. “She’s just saying what her values are.”
โ Anne Blythe
Around The State
Tricia Cothamโs Bargain
The former Democrat has paid a high personal price for switching parties. What did she get in return?
Trump and Harris Fight It Out Street by Street
North Carolina Republicans have had stronger get-out-the-vote efforts for more than a decade, but Democrats are determined to outwork them this year.
Don Davis Tries to Hold On in the Northeast
A Republican hasnโt held his district since 1883. But redistricting and shifting demographics have left the Democratic incumbent vulnerable.

The Assembly is a digital magazine covering power and place in North Carolina. Sent this by a friend? Subscribe to our newsletter here.






You must be logged in to post a comment.